Rubric

Keep in mind that 21 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Final Research Paper
Final Research Paper
Criteria Ratings Pts
Scientific communication
Uses relevant and robust evidence to substantiate claims. Conveys information at appropriate levels of scientific sophistication based on target audience
threshold: pts
10 to >9.0 pts Exceeds
9 to >8.0 pts Meets
8 to >7.0 pts Developing
7 to >0 pts Weak
pts
10 pts
--
Sources
Identifies and integrates appropriate peer-reviewed and reputable sources. Includes a minimum of 5 key sources, cited in APA style.
threshold: pts
10 to >9.0 pts Exceeds
9 to >8.0 pts Meets
8 to >7.0 pts Developing
7 to >0 pts Weak
pts
10 pts
--
Critical Analysis
Has a clear, arguable, and strong thesis statement. Critically compares and contrasts sources of information and takes a stance on the issue . Arguments are logical and organized.
threshold: pts
10 to >9.0 pts Exceeds
9 to >8.0 pts Meets
8 to >7.0 pts Developing
7 to >0 pts Weak
pts
10 pts
--
Audience
Identifies an audience and intent for the writing.
applies data/ideas to make clear what the audience should feel/think/do as a result of this information
threshold: pts
10 to >9.0 pts Exceeds
9 to >8.0 pts Meets
8 to >7.0 pts Developing
7 to >0 pts Weak
pts
10 pts
--
Mechanics
Writing is clear and grammar, spelling, and mechanics are sound. Writing is organized in a logical manner. The tone and style is appropriate for a research paper.
threshold: pts
10 to >9.0 pts Exceeds
9 to >8.0 pts Meets
8 to >7.0 pts Developing
7 to >0 pts Weak
pts
10 pts
--
Memo
Includes information on intended audience, instructor feedback, and identifies a strength and weakness
threshold: pts
5 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
5 pts
--