Peer review feedback

Peer review feedback document.docx Download Peer review feedback document.docx

For the two manuscripts you reviewed, please upload comments addressing the following points and complete the rubric attached. Note: this rubric includes the same writing metrics that will be used to assess your final version at the end of the semester. 

For the two manuscripts you reviewed, please upload comments addressing the following points and complete the rubric attached. Each review is worth 10 its (20 pts total).

For each of the drafts you reviewed, please include author's last name, and comment on:

1. What was one strength you noticed in this document?
2. What was one weakness you noticed about this document? What still needs to be developed?
3. Is there a clear thesis statement? Is the intent of the piece clear (is it written with an audience in mind)? How might this be improved?
4. Does the topic relate to the urban food system in some way? Is the connection clear?
5. Did the author make use of high-quality sources?Is there at least one peer-reviewed (journal article) source included? Are references cited within the text and listed at the end of the text?