Rubric

Self Reflection
Self Reflection
Criteria Ratings Pts
Defines their own views using external methods such as writing
threshold: pts
20 pts Exceptional: Student demonstrates a startling degree of insight
16 pts Nuanced: Student demonstrates a signifiant degree of knowledge, maturity, and insight in articulating their ideas
8 pts Simplistic: Student articulates only surface details with little to no insight
0 pts Student did not engage this part of the assignment
pts
20 pts
--
Identifies the ways in which their own views can evolve or contradict themselves over time
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceptional: Student demonstrates a startling degree of insights
8 pts Nuanced: Student demonstrates a signifiant degree of knowledge, maturity, and insight in articulating their ideas
4 pts Simplistic: Student articulates only surface details with little to no insight
0 pts Student did not engage this part of the assignment
pts
10 pts
--
Articulates clear positions that are informed by evidence or earlier informal reflections
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceptional: Student demonstrates a startling degree of insight
8 pts Nuanced: Student demonstrates a signifiant degree of knowledge, maturity, and insight in articulating their ideas
4 pts Simplistic: Student articulates only surface details with little to no insight
0 pts Student did not engage this part of the assignment
pts
10 pts
--
Discusses the ways in which positions may need to change in the face of later experience or evidence
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceptional: Student demonstrates a startling degree of insight
8 pts Nuanced: Student demonstrates a signifiant degree of knowledge, maturity, and insight in articulating their ideas
4 pts Simplistic: Student articulates only surface details with little to no insight
0 pts Student did not engage this part of the assignment
pts
10 pts
--